ABQ People’s Tribunal on Police Brutality

abq cops 2

(Note: if you’re unable to see the Tweets in their entirety, hold down Control, press-, then +, and they should justify.)

Beginning last September, over a dozen members of a coalition of ABQ Justice and related organizations spent six months on the streets interviewing citizens most often brutalized by the APD. Those include: the homeless, Latinos/Latinas, and First Americans.  Forty-one people agreed to be interviewed; many others had been asked, but declined, stating fear of reprisal as the reasons. The culmination of the report was to be presented at a People’s Tribunal on March 12, close to the one year anniversary of the horrific assassination of homeless James Boyd by the APD in the Sandia foothills north-east off the city.  More than seventy people attended the tribunal in a makeshift room decorated with photos of the murdered, as well as related placards of slogans related to the ongoing movement.

While a coalition of social justice groups had been asking the Department of Justice to investigate the APD’s rampant civil rights abuses since 2010, it was James ‘Abba’ Boyd’s assassination that caused the anti-police brutality movement to take fire in earnest.  Their combined and dogged efforts predated the #BlackLivesMatter movement, and I couldn’t appreciate them more.  They have managed to stop the killings, at least for now.

The impetus behind the investigation and tribunal was that neither the Department of Justice’s 2014 investigation of the department, nor the DOJ’s consent decree, which found that the APD engages in patterns of unconstitutional excessive force, including deadly force, but failed to address any racial and class bias against marginalized (read: expendable, undesirable citizens) as key underlying factors, as in: an entire culture of 2-tiered policing.

The APD was put on trial by citizen jurists.

(from left to right), Father Francis Quintana, Margaux Lopez, Charles Powell, Eleanor Chavez, Sam Gardipe, and Sally-Alice Thompson

The jurists who sat on Saturday’s tribunal are dedicated activists who represent social justice organizations in New Mexico:
Francis Quintana, founding pastor of the Blessed Oscar Romero Catholic Community.
Margaux Lopez, organizer for ANSWER New Mexico and Women Organized to Resist & Defend.
Charles Powell, president of the Albuquerque chapter of Veterans for Peace.
Eleanor Chavez of the American Federation of Teachers and District 1 representative on the Public Education Commission.
Sally Ellis Thompson, co-founder of the Albuquerque chapter of Veterans for Peace, co-founder of the Albuquerque Center for Peace and Justice, and member of Raging Grannies.
Sam Gardipe, co-founder of the Red Nation, dedicated to the liberation of indigenous peoples.

From Kay Matthews at LaJicarita.com:

“David Correia, one of the organizers of the tribunal and a professor of American Studies at UNM, laid out how the six month study was conducted and summarized the findings that were subsequently presented to the tribunal: 1) APD systematically engages in racially motivated forms of policing targeting people of color, particularly Native Americans; 2) APD engages in violence against women, including sexual violence; and 3) APD specifically and routinely engages in harassment of homeless people.

None of these charges are new. As several speakers told the tribunal, there is a history of APD engaging in racist profiling and violence. Richard Moore, of Los Jardines Institute, talked about the longtime struggles of the Latino community in Albuquerque to address this violence: the Brown Berets, the Poor People’s Campaign, the Black Berets, student and youth groups, Southwest Organizing Project (SWOP), and the Southwest Network of Environmental and Economic Justice all organized to expose systemic violence in APD, which resulted in the murder of several Chicano activists.”

Various testimonials gathered during their six months of interviews were read before those assembled; activists from various social justice organizations asked probing questions of experts who attended.  Roughly five fields of testimony were addressed: violence against people of color; violence against the homeless and working poor; violence against women and LGBTQ people; violence against people with mental healthcare needs; and systemic problems with APD training.”

Matthews notes that in this video of retired APD officer Sam Costales, you will hear him make these chilling statements:

“It would take hours to describe the violence I’ve witnessed by my fellow officers.”

When asked about the validity of the claim that mot cops are good, but that a ‘few bad apples’ ruin the department, he said, “I absolutely disagree that most cops are good cops.”

Asked whether or not Hispanic cops are less likely to engage in profiling people of color, Costales responded, “Once they put on a uniform they’re all blue.”  We’ve heard it expressed that when a black person dons the police uniform, they’put on white skin along with it’.

Unfortunately, the sound quality in this video makes it hard to watch, but it does get a little better as time goes on.

First People’s Tribunal on Police Brutality Pt 1

First People’s Tribunal on Police Brutality Pt 2
(you may notice Barabra Grothus behind Diana Vargas, then speaking at about 16 minutes.)

This is the Scribd version of the report: ‘Targeted: Prejudice and Racial Bias in the Albuquerque Police Department’. This report summarizes the findings of a six-month investigation of racial bias and prejudice by the Albuquerque Police Department by ABQJustice and the ANSWER Coalition.  Given that it’s eighteen pages including the appendix, I’ll clip a few bits of major interest and outrage, most of which are included in the videos.

It includes this gasp-worthy chart:

Note that Since January, 2010, the Albuquerque Police Department (APD) has killed 28 people in 42 officer-involved shootings, “a per-capita kill rate nearly double that of the Chicago police and eight times that of the NYPD.”


This is the first study to systematically acquire data by and about the people routinely victimized by APD, demonstrating that unconstitutional policing and unjustified use-force at APD is not only routine, but significantly underreported. The street interviews, conducted by teams of ABQJustice investigators, confirmed that:

  1. APD systematically engages in racially motivated forms of policing targeting people of color, particularly Native Americans.
  2. APD engages in violence against women, including sexual violence.
  3. 3. APD specifically and routinely engages in harassment of homeless people.


Te ABQJustice investigation shows that the po-lice oversight agencies, in place from 1997 to the present, have failed to resolve the systemic problems at APD. ABQJustice believes this is because the authority of these agencies is limited to an advisory capacity.The solutions outlined in this report call for:

  1. An independent agency with the authority to discipline officers and make policy changes.
  2. Routine extensive outreach to collect com-plaints against APD.
  3. The acceptance of anonymous complaints against APD.
  4. The decriminalization of homelessness.
  5. Police officers who use unjustified force must be held criminally accountable.
  6. The publishing of all officer shift rosters at the end of each week, and the immediate online posting of all lapel camera video.
  7. The recruitment of officer candidates who hold degrees, or have experience, in, social work or allied fields.
  8. Limiting promotion to officers who have experience in, or show an inclination for, community-based policing.

A number of the testimonies in red are extremely horrific, if expected.  I know we all thank these good people for their honest recounting of events.

A homeless Hispanic male in his 50s told investigators, “When a cop comes up to me I get scared. They always make an excuse. If I put my hand in my jacket to grab a cigarette butt, they say that I grabbed a gun.” He described constant harassment: “I can’t walk nowhere because they stop me. If I’m  just walking down the street they can’t just stop me and say ‘I want to see your ID;’ they say ‘I got prob-able cause to search you.’” He described an incident when he ran from police. He was unarmed. “Tey caught me. Tey took my jacket and put it over my head, kicked me in the head, split my head open. I had probably 38 staples in my head. They shattered every rib on my lef-hand side.”

A homeless White male in his 40s described harassment by APD officers that also included property destruction. When the interviewer asked whether local police had ever abused him, he explained, “Yeah, once the cops handcuffed me and made me watch them cut up my tent and sleeping bag with razor blades. They’re real bastards.” When the interviewer asked why APD did that, he responded, “Because they can. Because I’m homeless.”

Two homeless Native men and one homeless Native woman in their 40s described an APD attack on a friend, who is also homeless. According to all three, officers dragged their fiend into an alley where he was beaten. They did it “because he’s homeless and Native. And they continue to do it.” explained the woman. The interviewer asked if APD harassed them. “Yeah, [the police] cut up our IDs and social security cards.” They described frequently receiving citations for loitering. “They come up and give us a ticket for loitering. We go to court but can’t pay and we end up getting a warrant. We go to jail and get out in the morning.” They described this as a pattern that happened frequently.

Nearly every Native person interviewed de-scribed APD’s use of racial slurs, such as “dirty Indian.” They described encounters that began with APD officers telling them to “go back to the reservation.” One Native man reported: “I was walking on the street and [a cop] was following me. I’d go down the alley and he’d follow me. ‘Why don’t you go back to the rez. You’re not welcome here in Albuquerque,’ he told me.”

A homeless Jicarilla Apache man pointed to the ground. “This is ours, our land,” he said. “And the cops they’ll say things like ‘Why do you want to bring the reservation our way?’” ABQJustice investigators asked how often harassment is also violent. “It’s usually,” he said. He showed wrists covered in scabbed-over wounds he said were from handcuffs. He pulled off his sunglasses. One eye was red and swollen. “They maced me in this eye. They walked up to me from behind and maced me like this,” he said, as he put his hand inches from the interviewer’s eyes to show how it was done. “How common is this? Does this happen to everyone?” “Yes,” he said. “They handcuff you and then they beat you and then they take you to the hospital and say something like ‘we found him this way.’”

A young Native women was reluctant to talk to investigators but finally described an incident that happened in the fall of 2014. “Tis cop just drove up on me, got out and slammed my head into the pavement. Ten he just got in his car and drove away.” She was walking with a friend who described a constant pattern of harassment. “We’ll be waiting at the bus stop and cops will pull up and tell us to keep moving or they’ll arrest us for loitering.”

Father Francis Quintana of the Blessed Oscar Romero Catholic Community offered a statement about the excessive, brutal, and unjustifed force (often terminal) of the APD, and plea to them to stop it.

Melanie Yazzie from the Red Nation and member of the Diné nation testified that “The problem is colonization. Taking and stealing by force is a fundamental aspect of how all of this relates to Natives.”  Indeed it is.

One would have hoped that the People’s Tribunal had been covered by some mainstream media, but at least the UNM newspaper, The Daily Lobo did.  Via Jonathan Baca:

“Los Jardines Institute member Richard Moore, who has been an outspoken activist against APD violence for close to 50 years, presented this historical overview to the tribunal.

“The militarization of APD and the police forces have a long history. It’s not been recent over the last four or five years,” Moore said. “There’s some real historical pieces there that go along with this — brutality, harassment — that needs to be added to this whole story to make it a complete picture. In order to understand where we’re going, we ought to understand where we’re coming from.”

“Today was not the beginning, it’s not the end, but it’s a continuation of what needs to be done,” he said.

Correia said the ultimate goal is to build a large group of supporters, and then bring a more refined report to local government agencies.

“The city administration — Mayor Berry, City Administrator Rob Perry — have demonstrated no interest whatsoever in this issue,” he said. “They’re ultimately responsible because they can hire and fire the police chief.”

Perhaps more media will pick up the great story on their efforts.  Activists pushing back against police brutality and abject murder nationwide need to know of the tribunal and the report.  If you;re able to spread the word, please do so.

Related News and Opinions:

‘No Justice, No Peace, Without Black Community Control of Police’, by Glen Ford of Black Agenda Report‘Ferguson shooting suspect gave false confession, lawyer says Attorney’: yahoonews.com

‘Killer Cops in Madison; “Most Liberal City”, by Paul Gottinger

‘Depravity at the Highest Level: Obama Prepares the Boil from Selma’ – PART II and Black Code Alert, by Dr. Marsha Cole

“God gave Noah the rainbow sign. No more water, the fire next time!” — The Fire Next Time, James Baldwin

‘NYPD says cops won’t be sanctioned for altering Wikipedia entries’, RT.com

9 responses to “ABQ People’s Tribunal on Police Brutality

  1. I would care to comment, thank you for bringing these testimonies and brave souls who speak.

    I will forward these to people I know in WI who may not be aware of this type of forums. Some run state-read blogs wd. All the best, part two will have to wait for this evening.

  2. their strategies and tactics over the past year have been brilliant, haven’t they, nonquixote? courageous in civil disobedience and other direct actions, as well. it’s so good to hear that they realize that this is just another step along a long road that may lead to actual citizen control of the APD.

    thanks so much for being willing to send it out there. i’ve been conversing with miz grothus about seeing if any of their members Tweet (or would learn), and i’d give them some relevant accounts in the protestor movement to share either this or kay matthews’ fine piece.

    you may have missed this from the ‘2 cops shot near ferguson’ thread:

    ‘Another Racist Email Forward Found In Scott Walker’s Former Deputy Chief Of Staff Emails; A second racist email forward found in released messages from a former aide to Walker, then the Milwaukee County executive. “That is hilarious. And so true.” ‘


  3. Good Morning wendyedavis,
    Latest from the upper mid-west, in the Dontre Hamilton police shooting death case officer Manney has a appeal to be re-instated to his job today.


    A bit more from one of WI’s best public interest groups a recent article speaking to concerns about the direction of Madison WI policing and policy, future spending:


  4. Thanks, wd! You are an asset in the struggle!

  5. ‘suspicious bulge’: yessir, a cell phone battery would cause one of those, wouldn’t it? and eee-crikey: killer cops in los angeles trained under bill bratton would be just who i’d trust on ‘constitutionally correct police procedures’

    the pr watch piece (have only scanned it so far) seems to mirror the piece wayoutwest mentioned: ‘Killer Cops in Madison; “Most Liberal City”. i stuck that and a few other titles in the OP.

    this morning the guardian has another of the stories demonstrating that we shouldn’t call 911 for help for folks with mental health issues, in less: TINA.

    ‘Video released of Dallas police shooting mentally ill black man dead at home
    Footage show two officers fatally shooting Jason Harrison, who was holding a screwdriver, within minutes of arriving at home in response to emergency call’ (srsly hard to watch, i won’t embed the video)


    i was just telling mr. wd that there are soooo many stories of rape, brutality (including choking, kneeling on ‘suspects’ necks, tasing (increasingly *children at school*), tra la la..) by the po po and security guards that we mainly are forced to report on those who were *killed’ outright.

  6. hola, amiga! so glad you stopped by. glad to be able to give an assist to you righteous and ever-so-dedicated folks; i doff my cap. i regret this small venue is it for now, and it may permanently be so. i’m waiting to hear back from fdl management about that.

    solidarity, bg, and best ♥!

    on edit: i just heard from kevin g, and he says that it will be up to weeks before they know if my.fdl will survive. oddly heartening news, given what’s been said over yonder. ;)

  7. in the ‘at least he’s not dead’ category, but worthy of bringing his story, nonetheless:

    Mother Jones has some of the story. “Images and footage capturing the arrest of Martese Johnson, a University of Virginia student who needed 10 stitches after being arrested by state liquor police for allegedly having a fake ID, prompted large protests at UVA’s Charlottesville campus on Wednesday, with hundreds of students gathering to demand justice.

    Johnson, 20-years-old and a member of the school’s Honor Committee, was arrested on Tuesday by officers from the Virginia Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control as bystanders recorded the bloody encounter.”

    You might like to read this message from the Black Student Alliance at UVA
    https://www.facebook.com/bsaatuva?fref=nf, beginning:

    ‘Please see the below statement for details on the incident that occurred early this morning with our Leadership Development Chair, Martese Johnson…’

    and see how police treated some of the outraged protestors last night


  8. http://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2015/mar/19/senior-chicago-police-commander-resigns-homan-square
    “A senior Chicago police commander in charge of a major unit operating out of the controversial Homan Square police warehouse has resigned, the Guardian has confirmed.

    The news came as attorneys for three Homan Square victims announced that they would file the first civil rights lawsuit over the facility…”

  9. thank you so much, marym (in an undisclosed location). this is mind-boggling:

    “According to Chicago city data, Roti’s annual salary was $176,532. A local website cited Roti in 2014 as the 16th highest-paid public official in Chicago. The superintendent of police, cited as the highest paid Chicago public servant, is listed as making $260,000 annually. Mayor Rahm Emanuel makes $216, 210.

    The Chicago police have yet to respond to a request for further information.”

    holy hell, and chicago rising is keeping the pressure on. including over the murder of rekia boyd.

care to comment? (no registration required)

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s